Graderworks 2.3 Release

by: Anthony Garland

UPDATE: Changed from experimental to production on 8/9/2016. No known bugs exist.

Graderworks 2.3 is now available. This version may contain a few minor bugs.

 

New features include 

  1. Similarity scores can now be computed using just .stl files. This function lets you compare 1000s of .stl files against a target reference .stl file. For example, if you use another CAD application, then you could export models as .stl files and compare the models against a target 'correct' file. Or, you could download 1000s of files from Thingiverse and compare how similar they are to your particular .stl design. 
  2. Scaling of files for similarity checking. Often files are alike but at a different scale. For example, a student might draw a metric part in inches. Therefore, we expect all the dimensions to be exactly 1:0.0254 smaller than the correct shape. In the past, the similarity score would have been zero, since the algorithm requires the two parts be on the same scale. Now, Graderworks will try automatically scaling the part, and then comparing the parts at the new scale. For each reference file, 3 columns will be generated. 
    1. The similarity score without scaling. This score is the standard score that was used before. 
    2. The scale between current file and target reference. Graderworks will attempt to scale the current model to be the same size as the target reference. It will export the scaling factor in this column. 
    3. The similarity score of the scaled file. After scaling the current file, the similarity score will be computed again. 
  3. Reference file properties analyzed. When specifying one or more reference files for the geometric similarity comparison check, the mass properties and meta-data will be exported in the first few lines of the output.CSV file. This information is helpful since often it is used for grading. 

 

Example

As an example of the similarity score comparison of .stl files compared to .stl files, I will give a short example analyzing 'wheel' files from Thingiverse. I downloaded several wheels from Thingiverse, put them into a single folder, copied the absolute file path of this folder to the root folder textbox in Graderworks, selected '.Stl files' as the assignment type, and entered 'Volant.stl' as the reference to compare against, and checked the "Compare Part to References Specified Below" and "Autoscale and Recompare" checkboxes. 

 

 

Files

Download the files here.

Run

After running Graderworks (Analysis->Start), the output.Csv file showed the raw similarity, scaling factors, and scaled similarities after scaling. 

After manual scaling the parts according to column E, this is the size they look on the build platform. 

Conclusion

The similarity score at first seems suspiring since we think of all wheels the same. Indeed, we think in terms of schemas of what constitutes a wheel. We have a mental model of what 'wheelness' means. While examining the results, the key geometric features that raise the similarity score are 1. The width of the wheel and 2. having spokes of some sort. 

To test this hypothesis, I drew a simple wheel in SOLIDWORKS and then reran the comparison. As expected, my wheel with a simple rim and spokes had a high similarity score when compared to the reference model, 'volant'. I put the test wheel on Thingiverse. 

 

Try it!

Give Graderworks a try even if you don't have SOLIDWORKS on you computer. Graderworks only takes about 2 minutes to download and install! Try analyzing some .stl files and let me know what you think!

Download it here.

.stl files with errors do not work well with Graderworks. So be sure your file is a manifold.


Join our free mailing list!

Join our free mailing list!


Graderworks

  • Grade student's SOLIDWORKS files quickly
  • Catch Plagiarism
  • Export SOLIDWORKS files to another format in bulk
View Software

Recent Articles

Graderworks: SW 2017, Config files, Command line args

Graderworks 2.36 and higher is compatible with SOLIDWORKS 2017. Graderworks now


Graderworks: An Official SOLIDWORKS Solution Partner

Garland Industries is happy to announce that Graderworks is now an official SOL


Graderworks 2.35

Several more improvements have been made to Graderworks in version 2.35.


Graderworks 2.32 Release

Graderworks 2.32 represents continued incremental improvement in the overall qua


ROI of Graderworks

Graderworks saves educational institutions $625 per semester for a Solidworks en


Design Automation Example

A design automation example is given showing topology optimization coupled with


Graderworks 2.31

Graderworks 2.31 includes the following updates. 1. When analyzing .stl files th


Graderworks 2.3 Update

Update on Graderworks 2.3 Several major bugs were fixed.


Graderworks 2.3 Release

Graderworks 2.3 allows you to compare the geometric similarity of .stl files wit


Turnitin vs. Graderworks

Graderworks is the Turnitin of 3D models. Not using a plagiarism checker in a So


Getting Started with Graderworks

This tutorial shows how to get started analyzing and grading Solidworks part fil


The Making of Graderworks Video

As an engineering entrepreneur, marketing is not my strength. To make high-quali


Organizing hundreds of .stl files for 3D printing

How would you 3D print hundreds of .stl files in the shortest time possible usin


What is unique about 3D printing?

3D Printing offers many new exciting possibilities, but why is it unique? Three


How 3D printing works

3D Printing requires three steps. 1. Getting a 3D model. 2. Slicing the model to


Preprocessing files for Graderworks: Converting .rar to .zip

Solidworks students submit .rar files instead of .zip. Graderworks requires .zip


Windows Smart Screen and Code Signing

A short tutorial on how to sign a Windows installer and what the smart screen fi


What should we 3D print?

3D Printing opens the possibility of mass customization of consumer products. Ma


How did Graderworks Evolve?

How would you grade 1000s of Solidworks file? This article is the story of how I


Software, dying on the journey from academic project to commercial tool. 

Does software make it from academic research to useful commercial tools? Ignoran